°µÍø½ûÇø

Spoiler Alert: Everyone on the show got hit by an Asteroid, so I guess Deportation was not the big issue, however please let me know.😮

Certainly a permanent visa is a privilege, not a right, and can be taken off you for serious crime (but not minor stuff!).

01/29/25 Even if you have Permanant Residency or Citizenship are their situations where you can be deported for certain actions?

Roddie in Retirement🕵 - @roddiesho

Not for random bad acts.  Under the Law of Migration, a resident can lose his/her residency if the cause for originally granting the residency ceases to exist, if s/he is out of Brazil for two continuous years or more without a justification acceptable to the PF, or if the residency was obtained on the basis of fraud. (DECRETO Nº 9.199, DE 20 DE NOVEMBRO DE 2017).  In all of these cases, the resident has the opportunity to appeal.  If a resident foreigner is convicted of a sufficiently serious crime, the court can order his/her authorization of residency revoked once all appeals have been exhausted.

It's practically impossible to lose Brazilian Citizenship whether obtained through birth or naturalization without voluntarily giving it up.  A naturalization can be revoked if it was based on fraud, and there are a few other pretty extreme crimes that can result in revocation after final conviction.

Certainly a permanent visa is a privilege, not a right, and can be taken off you for serious crime (but not minor stuff!). - @Peter Itamaraca

I have noticed that most people who move from one country to another are for reasons other than to engage in criminal activities in a new country. That's why a clean criminal background check by Brazil is a smart requirement.

There is probably an extremely small percentage of people who are rich or powerful enough to falsify or circumvent those requirements. Deportation would be a welcome relief but it will take a really big effort to find and prove. I am grateful that there is a law on the books for those.

I think that illegals would most likely contribute to the criminal element - as they would most likely fail the legitimate route.

Typically not something to worry about for someone who has followed the legal route.

@roddiesho - Hollywood movies and movies in general tend to exaggerate or touch on sensitive issues - just to hype things up. Deportation in the US is definitely something that is on most minds nowadays....

@Pablo888 Yes, but honestly, I did not even think about it once I got my Brazilian Permanent Residency.  In the show the character only took action after he was attacked and did not know the person who did it was a police officer. Even in real life it is not unheard of for someone to push you at a soccer game or try to steal your phone. It would be nothing if you pulled away and that person was hurt. Even the best intentions can cause harm.

I am glad they did that episode, though having them ALL killed by an Asteroid, kinda kept me from knowing if he was actually deported.

Roddie in Retirement. 🕵

@Pablo888 Your comment “I think that illegals would most likely contribute to the criminal element “ is a huge part of the problem in the US right now. The avenue to citizenship there has been made so difficult and so costly that most people can’t afford it. Here on this forum, I see many people concerned because they have overstayed due to negligence, romance or any number of reasons, but I think it’s a huge stretch to say people come illegally to commit crimes.

@Pablo888 Your comment “I think that illegals would most likely contribute to the criminal element “ is a huge part of the problem in the US right now. The avenue to citizenship there has been made so difficult and so costly that most people can’t afford it. Here on this forum, I see many people concerned because they have overstayed due to negligence, romance or any number of reasons, but I think it’s a huge stretch to say people come illegally to commit crimes. - @sjpetzold

@sjpetzold, I sympathize with your thought and understand that most illegals currently in the US are mostly economic and political refugees.  I volunteer in a church who prepares food and provides shelter for them.

I do not mean to disregard the legitimate ones but there is an immigration process.  It is unfortunate that there is currently an anti-immigration attitude all over the world.

The topic is about deportation and unfortunately it is hard to distinguish between a legitimate refugee and one who may have nefarious intents.

For those following my deportation story. The 126 did not perish after the Asteroid landed in their city nor did they perish in the Nuclear Meltdown following it, so the one firefighter was not deported even though he told the Judge to kiss his @@@.

So, this was a tv show in case you may be wondering if it could happen to you.

Roddie in Retirement🕵